When Will a Food Market Open in Scarsdale?

An aerial view of the plan for the new Piccolino market in Scarsdale.Another Thanksgiving is here, and there’s still no market in Scarsdale. The original DeCicco’s closed its doors just over a year ago, and the new DeCicco’s (same name, different owners) said they planned to open the new market, called Piccolino, by the end of 2025.

However, things were looking quiet so we stopped by DeCicco’s Eastchester location to get an update.

It turns out that a complete gut renovation of the site is underway – from the basement up. It’s taking longer than planned – and DeCicco’s is also in the process of constructing a store in Glenville – so that could be further slowing progress here in Scarsdale.

Joe DeCicco said they have concerns about the limited size of the parking lot in Scarsdale and hope to arrange additional parking for customers in the Village. They will also make it possible to order and pick up or use Instacart to speed the process in the store.

The question remains – when will we be able to buy a dozen eggs in Scarsdale instead of driving to White Plains, Eastchester or Central Avenue? As of now, they are targeting May, 2026.